When Donald Trump became President, many people thought the election would bring about long-awaited U.S. Tax reform in the United States.
But not everyone.
According to federal government records, a record 5,409 Americans renounced their citizenships in the year 2016, including a whopping 2,364 in the final quarter of the year alone. That’s a more than 26% increase from the 4,279 who handed in their passports in 2015.
The cause of the defections, which led the U.S. To say so long last quarter to everyone from Jonathan Abbis to Anna Zwirner, is primarily the U.S. Tax system.
When it comes to taxes, the United States is an outlier because, unlike nearly every other country, it taxes people based on nationality rather than residency. While U.S. Citizens can claim credits with the IRS for what they pay to foreign tax authorities, those amounts are not always enough to offset what they owe.
U.S. Expats also face the burden of annual filings with the IRS with the prospect of stiff penalties if they fail to comply.
According to international tax attorney Andrew Mitchel, those who deliberately fail to report foreign accounts to the IRS can face a fine of $100,000 or half the value of the account—whichever is greater. Meanwhile, there are a range of other penalties for small business owners abroad and for those with assets of more than $30,000.
“The IRS has been very gracious in saying they won’t take more than 100% of your money,” says Mitchel, ironically. “These people are terrified they will go bankrupt because of the United States. They just want to get out of the U.S. Tax system.”
The upshot is that Americans living abroad—many of whom acquired citizenship as a child or married someone in another country decades ago—are simply choosing to give up their citizenship rather than face the ongoing tax hassle. But even renouncing comes at a cost as those who want to surrender their passports must first pay application fees and settle up any outstanding debts.
Get Data Sheet, Coins2Day ‘s technology newsletter.
Meanwhile, despite calls for reform by U.S. Ex-patriates groups and media outlets like the Wall Street Journal, there’s little hope the law will be changed anytime soon. According to Mitchel, the discussions taking place in Congress for a once-in-a-generation overhaul of the tax system are focusing on extra-territorial corporate taxes, not individual tax-payers. (Meanwhile, as Coins2Day editor Alan Murray explained in Monday’s CEO Daily newsletter, the hopes for a major tax deal in Washington are already fading).
As for the source of the current uptick in Americans renouncing their citizenship, it lies in a law that requires overseas banks to tell the IRS about American customers.
“To some degree it is President Obama’s fault. It was Obama and the Democratic Congress that passed a law in 2010 that forced foreign banks to disclose U.S. Citizens,” says Mitchel.
When the law was passed, it appeared to be aimed at fat cats who sought to hide money in secret Swiss bank accounts. But today, it could affect nearly any of the 7 million Americans, who Mitchel says live abroad—many of whom are people of modest means.
There are, though, some famous names among the latest list of foreign Americans. These include Boris Johnson, the former mayor of London and current Foreign Affairs minister for the United Kingdom.
Johnson, who has not lived in the United States since he was five years old, appears to have been motivated by an IRS bill for the capital gains he earned on the sale of his house in London.
“The United States comes after me, would you believe it … for capital gains tax on the sale of your first residence which is not taxable in Britain, but they’re trying to hit me with some bill, can you believe it?,” Johnson told NPR in a 2014 interview reported by The Guardian.
If you want to see a full list of every former American who renounced their citizenship in 2016, I’ve prepared a spreadsheet based on the government data accessible here.
(This story was updated at 8:20am ET to reflect it was the Democratic, not Republican, Congress who passed the 2010 law)