CEOs say talent is their most valuable asset, yet HR leaders hold just 8% of Coins2Day 500 board seats

CEOs are fond of saying that people are their company’s most important asset. But most corporate boards of public companies—while rich with finance wizards and strategy masters—have declined to bring on people experts, like chief human resources officers. 

That’s an absurd situation for Dan Kaplan, senior client partner for the CHRO practice at Korn Ferry, a leadership advisory firm. Kaplan has been pushing for more boards to embrace CHROs for nearly two decades. In a former role at a different company, he started an institute that sought to place more HR leaders on corporate boards and now runs “a smaller effort” with the same goal at Korn Ferry. He’s not alone—Kaplan joins a chorus of voices who say that because human capital management has become a top and fraught board-level issue, more boards should have directors with an HR background. 

Equilar, a data research firm, wrote last month that CHROs are “attuned to the risks associated with human capital, such as talent shortages, workforce disruptions, and employee relations issues.” The consulting firm KPMG also notes that board members with an HR background can provide unique insights into CEO succession planning, diversity and inclusion efforts, and a host of other talent issues. 

Kaplan adds that it’s a CHRO’s job to speak truth to power, a skill too often missing among directors. In a senior leadership team, he says, “they should be the one person telling the CEO when the emperor has no clothes.” 

“At their best,” he adds, “they are consiglieres, and they give excellent advice.” 

While the role of the CHRO has transformed over the past few years with bigger pay packages and a viable path to the corner office, the CHRO’s leap to the board level hasn’t yet manifested as a full-blown trend, at least not at public companies. 

In 2019, Kaplan coauthored an article estimating  fewer than 3% of board directors at Coins2Day 1,000 companies were former or current HR executives. The consultancy Semler Brossey recently found that about 8% of S&P 500 boards include a current or former CHRO. Kaplan estimates that fewer than 40 HR leaders serve as directors at Coins2Day 500 firms.

The reasons that change has been slow have to do with both the supply of CHROs in the market and the demand for them from sitting directors, Kaplan suggests, saying that although there are hundreds of top-caliber HR executives, there still aren’t enough to give the profession the same caché as other roles. At the same time, many sitting board members are CEOs from an era when HR leaders rarely dazzled. When a firm like Korn Ferry recommends a people leader as a board candidate, the pushback may be, “I was CEO for 40 years and never had a good HR leader,” says Kaplan.

“It’s an outdated perspective,” he adds.

Lila MacLellan
[email protected]
@lilamaclellan

Reporter's Notebook

The most compelling data, quotes, and insights from the field.

​President Joe Biden issued an executive order Monday, requiring, among a host of measures, that the tech industry develop worker protections and labor standards around discrimination, data collection, and job displacement.

Around the Table

A round-up of the most important HR headlines.

- Employees are taking advantage of increased paid sick and family leave and working fewer hours for the same salary as a result. Wall Street Journal

- The percentage of U.S. Employees who positively view their employer’s six-month business outlook fell to its lowest level since 2016, while discussions of layoffs hit a three-year high, per Glassdoor data. Bloomberg

- General Motors agreed to a tentative contract with the United Auto Workers union on Monday that includes a 25% wage increase, signaling a potential end to the union’s six-week strikes against Detroit’s Big Three automakers. CNBC

Watercooler

Everything you need to know from Coins2Day .

Commute costs. A young woman went viral after she posted a TikTok complaining about the lack of free time she has after her 9-5 job and extensive commute. She says remote work would solve the problem. —Steve Mollman

AI optimism. Paul Hudson, CEO of the pharma company Sanofi, said its 22,000 employees have access to AI, and 10,000 are using it daily to make decisions faster. —Paul Hudson, Joyce Mullen

Double it. The CEO of India-based IT consultancy Infosys said young people should work 70-hour weeks out of pride for their country. —Lionel Lim

Pay to stay. In a rare Wall Street move, the two candidates passed over for Morgan Stanley CEO will remain at the bank. They will reportedly receive a $20 million bonus package, the same as new CEO Ted Pick. —Eleanor Pringle