In the final few weeks of the presidential race, some polls and prediction markets are indicating we could have Donald Trump back in office come January 2025. For the first time since August, the former president overtook Vice President Kamala Harris in The Economist’s statistical model of America’s presidential election, and some other news outlets and political forecasters are predicting the same outcome.
Prediction markets like Polymarket and PredictIt also show Trump winning the election, but by a much steeper margin than some of the polls. As of Wednesday, Polymarket users have indicated Trump has nearly a 64% chance of winning the election, with Harris trailing at just 36%. PredictIt shows Trump in the lead with a 59% chance and Harris at 43%.
Alex Marinier, a venture capitalist who was one of the first to invest in Polymarket’s seed round in 2020, told Coins2Day it’s entirely possible that “some large whale is placing large bets that move the market.”
“They’re either super convinced that Trump would win, or explicitly to influence the market optics in favor of their candidate in an effort to help his odds of being elected,” Marinier said. “However, if the market believes that this whale bettor is, in fact, too optimistic on their candidate, then market forces should bring the market odds back to ‘correct’ market levels.”
And that appears to be exactly what’s happening. Starting earlier this month, four Polymarket accounts started pouring millions of dollars’ worth of bets that Trump would win the election. And Polymarket just told the New York Times‘ Dealbook that all four accounts—Polymarket users Fredi9999, Theo4, PrincessCaro, and Michie, which bet a collective $28 million that Trump would win the 2024 presidential election—are all owned by one French national with “extensive trading experience.”
Polymarket said it made contact with the trader and found no evidence of market manipulation, saying the trader was “taking a directional position based on personal views of the election.” The site added the French trader agreed “not to open further accounts without notice.”
What’s notable about Polymarket is that it’s a cryptocurrency-based prediction market—and Americans aren’t even allowed to trade on the website. As a result, Polymarket conducts checks to verify that major users on the platform are based outside of the U.S., a person familiar with the matter told Bloomberg.
This could be a key element in cracking the code on why Trump is seemingly pulling so far ahead of Harris, especially since only a handful of Polymarket users appear to be swaying the election odds.
Another Polymarket user, zxgngl, has been on a buying spree in recent days, betting more than $5 million worth of crypto on Trump retaking the Oval Office. With more than $35 million in bets being quickly poured into the presidential election market, it’s no wonder Trump appears to be ahead.
Are prediction markets accurate at all?
Some political and betting experts have said prediction markets are the most accurate way to foresee election outcomes because people are betting real money on a particular outcome. The way prediction markets work is that traders buy shares depending on which outcome they think is more likely. Share prices or “odds” rise and fall depending on demand, so if the event happens the way the trader predicted, the contract or “bet” will rise to $1 and pay out—or fall to $0 if it does not.
“Political betting sites are the best at predicting the wisdom of the crowd,” Thomas Miller, a data scientist at Northwestern University, told Coins2Day’s Shawn Tully. Miller is known for his accurate calls for the 2020 election, and some of his methodology comes from examining prediction markets.
But other experts aren’t so sure, particularly since Polymarket allows users to place bets only using cryptocurrency—and U.S. Voters aren’t even allowed to participate.
“I could not disagree more with that thesis,” George Kailas, CEO of stock-market intelligence tool Prospero.ai, told Coins2Day. “People are spending money around what they want to happen, not some strong underlying logic or reason.”
Plus, given that Polymarket is crypto-based and Trump is pro-crypto, “it would seem to be an indicator that Trump supporters are just more willing to bet on him than ‘wisdom,’” Kailas adds.
To be sure, Cliff Young, a pollster and president of public affairs for Ipsos, told Coins2Day betting markets are “about as good as the polls.” Although the “Presidential Election Winner 2024” market shows Trump with a great advantage over Harris, the “Popular Vote Winner 2024” shows Harris in the lead. Young said this could be because Trump appears to be stronger in the swing states.
While “Harris leads in the national race, which has leaned Democrat over the last few decades, the swing states define the election,” Young said.